TL;DR: apparently the management at my apartment complex considers plants to be “Seasonal decoration.” Here’s the email chain:
My landlord: You are in violation of your lease with the condition of your patio/deck area. The only thing allowed on your porch is patio furniture. Correct the issues shown in the attachment ASAP! If you have any questions please contact the property Manager M-F 9 am – 5 pm.
Thank You from our office staff and maintenance team! [Attached photo: My balcony seen from below, showing my one plant.]
Me: I’ve just re-read my lease agreement and could not find the clause you are referring to. The closest thing I could find is this, from the Community Rules Addendum, Use of Unit and Common Areas:
“3. It is the Tenant’s responsibility to keep balconies and patios in a clean and orderly condition. Storing of cartons, garbage, boxes, appliances, or other visually objectionable items on the patio or balcony is prohibited. Clotheslines or clothes hanging over balconies are not permitted. Hanging clothes and towels out to dry or use of the patio or balcony as a general storage area is not permitted. Seasonal and holiday decorations are not allowed without prior written permission from Landlord. If allowed, seasonal and holiday decorations must be reasonable, must not interfere with or disturb other tenants’ quiet enjoyment of the Community, and must be promptly removed within a reasonable time after the holiday, not to exceed 14 days or as otherwise directed by Landlord. Grilling or barbecuing is not permitted on balconies or patios.”
It does NOT say “The only thing allowed on your porch is patio furniture,” nor does it make any mention of prohibiting plants. If you are referring to another clause, please let me know.
My landlord: While there is no direct mention of potted plants, they fall under the category of seasonal and holiday decoration.
Potted plants are considered seasonal items not currently permitted by the property manager. If you would like to, you may stop by our leasing office during the week to speak with the property manager regarding the use of unit and common areas.
Me: Plants are not “seasonal and holiday decoration.” They are plants. They do not get put away for the winter, they do not celebrate a holiday, they just sit there. All year long. If potted plants are not permitted, then the lease agreement needs to be rewritten to reflect that. The lease which I signed does not prohibit potted plants.
My landlord: If you have any comments or concerns regarding use of unit common areas, please stop by our leasing office to speak directly with our property manager.
Me: If you have any further concerns, please contact me via email. Otherwise, I consider this matter resolved.
Thank you for your understanding
(That last email was sent after closing time. I guess I’ll find out tomorrow how that goes over.)
Landlord is wrong and clearly doesn’t have a leg to stand on, which is why they are so pathetically resorting to calling your plant “seasonal or holiday decoration”. They are also a joyless knuckle-dragging shithead.
Agreed.
One time, the apartment complex I was living at said I was violating my lease for keeping a storage container on my balcony. It was a small, zip up greenhouse with plants in it, which they allowed. When I confronted them about it, they admitted that they only observed it from the ground (I was on the 3rd floor) and that it was fine after all. That “violation” still appears on my rental history today, as the next apartment I rented asked me to explain why there was a violation on my file. Fuck this system.
Wait, there’s a permanent record? WTF, this is news to me.
A lot of properties are modernizing now and using software/systems that has history they can pass on to other complexes when they are called for references.
It’s part of the reason I left my old job as a technician. They were wanting me to install an app on my personal cell phone that would gps track me when I was on a work order and when pictures were taken for work orders. Not to mention they were using paycor and required gps tracking on when using it to clock in/out. When I started there we had paper time cards and carbon copy work orders.
Soulless corporations they are. Nickel and dime you to death.
Sorry, bit of a rant but stay away at any cost.
Yeah, at that point they should issue you a work phone.
No, there isn’t. Why would a landlord help other landlords? They’re competition.
My fellow Lemmy-ite, let me introduce you to the concept of corporate collusion:
https://www.reuters.com/legal/litigation/fight-is-control-realpage-antitrust-litigation-2023-01-10/
Here is a recent and ongoing example of how software services can be used (allegedly) by property management companies to avoid competition for the benefit of all (property management companies).
UPDATE: 24 hours after my last email to the landlord, and still no response. Not as satisfying as an acknowledgement that they were wrong (or maybe even… an apology?) but I’m pretty sure that means I’m in the clear, and the plant is safe.
That’s encouraging. Hopefully they’ll give it up. It’s ridiculous that anyone pursued this in the first place.
Plants are “seasonal & holiday”?
Someone please notify Earth to put away it’s “seasonal & holiday” decor.
FFSThat is moronic. If they can ban all-year potted plants as ‘seasonal decorations’ then words have no meaning and they can literally call anything ‘seasonal decorations’.
Stand your ground, or they might be back to tell you your TV, fridge and toilet are seasonal decorations too.
Your landlord is a piece of work! You handled it brilliantly, though. Anytime there is a building-wide notice with anything legal cited, I look it up; every damn time they are twisting some existing bylaw to try to control tenants.
Long live your plant! They look very happy and healthy :)
I think I already know the answer to this, but wtf is it about landlords never wanting to discuss things through email? Or text?
After my landlord continued to say “let’s discuss this in person” I finally just said “no, I would like a record of the conversation, thanks.” The noise complaint I initially contacted them about has never been solved a year later and I still live with the neighbors stomping day in and out. They wanted “proof,” I sent them multiple videos with audio. They wanted me to call maintenance, I called maintenance - because the landlord insisted it was something in the pipes (?) When I discussed it with maintenance, they said they knew it wasn’t. Nothing changed after they came, (they just looked at some kind of vent on the roof) but the landlord seemed satisfied that they’d tried, even though it did nothing. The landlord had been trying to go around the maintenance work order form online and have them call me instead. I filled out a form anyway.
I didn’t mean to go on a rant, it’s just so frustrating when you know that they know that they’re in the wrong, but there’s nothing you can do except take as many notes as possible in case it gets bad later on.
Good luck, I hope your plant prevails.
You handled it great. I think you have a good chance of winning this one! Looking forward to your update in which you tell us that your landlord backed off :D
They’re maniacs, they blew it up, oh damn them, god them them, what the hell
