The “larping” is that there are some genuine radical feminist critiques that worry that people transition to align with gender roles. Rhetoric online, which is often shitposting by transgender people, creates ecosystems where only TERFs talk to other TERFs, seeing posts which do seem to boil down to “clothes = gender” and this leads to a false understanding that people transition because of gender roles.
It was a complicated discussion that was happening before 2010 - see arguments over MichFest. But, in the 2010s, trans people started becoming the target du jour, and a combination of weirdos from the sex negative wing of feminism that were delighted to have people start paying attention to them and 4chan /pol/ saboteurs/alt righters delighted that they could dig up feminist critiques (eg, primarily Daly(? too drunk to Google)‘s The Transexual Empire and lesbian feminist essays from the 70’s (lesbian feminism is not lesbian feminists - lesbian feminism understands sexuality as a choice/about male separatism and thus has never been popular with actual lesbians)) and get “SJWs” to team up with them against a minority group…
“One unfortunate aspect of the alt-right movement is that it allows people to larp as libertarians to justify bigotry.”
If this statement doesn’t change how you see what you’re writing, I don’t know what will.
The “larping” is that there are some genuine radical feminist critiques that worry that people transition to align with gender roles. Rhetoric online, which is often shitposting by transgender people, creates ecosystems where only TERFs talk to other TERFs, seeing posts which do seem to boil down to “clothes = gender” and this leads to a false understanding that people transition because of gender roles.
It was a complicated discussion that was happening before 2010 - see arguments over MichFest. But, in the 2010s, trans people started becoming the target du jour, and a combination of weirdos from the sex negative wing of feminism that were delighted to have people start paying attention to them and 4chan /pol/ saboteurs/alt righters delighted that they could dig up feminist critiques (eg, primarily Daly(? too drunk to Google)‘s The Transexual Empire and lesbian feminist essays from the 70’s (lesbian feminism is not lesbian feminists - lesbian feminism understands sexuality as a choice/about male separatism and thus has never been popular with actual lesbians)) and get “SJWs” to team up with them against a minority group…