It is Stardate 2369.2, and Enterprise is docked at Starbase One. Chief Fleet Inspector Commander Pelia from Operational Support Services and her team are performing systems checks and upgrades.
No lawyer will take up Una’s case, not even the lawyer Pike and Una have in mind. The authorities have offered Una a plea deal but Pike advises urges her not to resign. Pike offers to confront the lawyer face to face. She is on the other side of the quadrant, 2.5 days round trip in “one of the newer shuttles”, indicating they are warp capable. Spock becomes Acting Captain, although he points out the lack of a Chief Engineer, a Security Chief and Una’s absence.
M’Benga notes Spock seems to be suffering from stress. He points out that Vulcan emotions are stronger than human ones, but that they control them through suppressive cognitive blocks. Spock removed those blocks to fight the Gorn (SNW: “All Those Who Wander”), so his emotions are flowing more freely.
M’Benga presents Spock with a lyre, to help him channel emotion into expression. The lyre was first seen in TOS: “Charlie X”, and subsequent appearances in canon have established it as a Vulcan lyre (or lute). This suggests that it was M’Benga who gifted Spock his lyre at this moment. This is consistent with M’Benga being familiar with Vulcans because he did his internship on the planet (TOS: “A Private Little War”). Spock’s heart rate goes down as he plays it, only for him to stop and have it shoot up when Chapel enters.
Chapel tells M’Benga she’s thinking about applying for a fellowship in archeological medicine, which will be 2 months on Vulcan. This is probably how she will meet her future fiancé Dr Roger Korby (TOS: “What Are Little Girls Made Of?”), who was a renowned figure in the field.
Ortegas has reversed the pitch and yaw controls on her helm console because the standard configuration wasn’t fast enough for her. Uhura is at the communications station and is no longer wearing her cadet insignia, indicating she’s graduated and is an Ensign.
Uhura tells Spock she has detected a distress signal from La’An originating in the Cajitar system, on the edge of Klingon space. April denies Spock permission to investigate, despite the message saying that there is a dangerous, anti-Federation threat on Cajitar IV and Enterprise’s resources are critical. Cajitar IV is a rich dilithium mining planet - the Federation alternates access to it with the Klingons thanks to a carefully negotiated treaty and for this month it’s the Klingons’ shift. If Enterprise shows up it will be an act of war.
Spock briefs the featured crew, including navigator LT Jenna Mitchell, on his plan to get the inspectors off the ship and steal the Enterprise to help La’An. This foreshadows Kirk & Co. famously doing the same thing to help Spock in ST III, a sequence called “Stealing the Enterprise” on the soundtrack album.
Mitchell triggers an intermix chamber coolant leak alert in Engineering. Plasma coolant dissolves flesh, as seen in ST: First Contact, and lack of coolant can cause a warp core breach.
Pelia teaches a course in warp core breaches at Starfleet Academy. Heightened temperatures around an intermix chamber is the most common factor mistaken for a breach. Purposely simulating coolant leak on the sensors violates about 17 Starfleet regulations.
Pelia notes the Vulcan inability to lie (a myth, as we’ve seen on several occasions, and Spock will get much better at it in future) and that they don’t do things without a good reason. She reveals she knows that Spock is Amanda Grayson’s son and suggests Ortegas to vent ionized plasma from the warp nacelles. Doing so triggers an alert on Starbase One, with Docking Control blowing the docking clamps and ordering Enterprise to make space between the ship and the station.
Pelia offers her services as Chief Engineer and says it’s been 100 years since she’s gone out with engines of her own. Ortegas scoffs, and Pelia says it’s a really long story. Uhura identifies her accent as Lanthanite, and Pelia confirms it.
Spock’s go-to-warp catchphrase is, “I would like the ship to go. Now.” Mitchell’s previous captain’s was “Zoom”, and Ortegas has been workshopping “vámanos” (“let’s go” in Spanish).
On Cajitar IV, La’An wins a bloodwine drinking contest with a Klingon, Kr’Dogh. She gets a meeting with someone named Greynax. One wonders how La’An is outdrinking a Klingon since the sense was that she was not genetically enhanced like her relative Khan - unless we’re being set up for another revelation like with Una, which might be over egging it with two genetically modified people in the main cast.
M’Benga approaches La’An, drawing a line under his eye with a finger like he did in SNW: “Strange New Worlds”.
Cajitar IV became a valuable source of dilithium during the war. When it ended, a new mining syndicate made up of ex-Klingon and Federation soldiers decided peace was bad for business and want to restart the war. To an unknown end, they are acquiring Federation technology, and a recent mining explosion exposed the town to ion radiation, including Oriana’s parents. M’Benga says that ion radiation isn’t from dilithium, but can be created by photon torpedoes.
Both Chapel and M’Benga served in the Klingon War (she implies that they served together). M’Benga likes reading up on weapons systems, and notes that the war produced 100 million Federation deaths for “a parsec of space or two”.
M’Benga and Chapel go to offer aid to the afflicted, and Oriana recognizes them. M’Benga suggests inducing recombination to repair genetic damage on her parents, which Chapel administers via a hypospray. They are then taken at gunpoint by a female Klingon and her henchmen.
(Continued in comments)
I appreciate posts like this even or especially because I watched the episode.
I connected Spock’s willingness to steal the ship for La’an more directly to his willingness to do so later for Pike.
Yes, but thematically, the phrase “steal the Enterprise” - and the heist aspect of it, whereas in TOS: “The Menagerie” it’s a more of a one-man show - is more associated with Kirk & Co. because of the sequence in ST III.
Spock briefs the featured crew, including navigator LT Jenna Mitchell, on his plan to get the inspectors off the ship and steal the Enterprise to help La’An. This foreshadows Kirk & Co. famously doing the same thing to help Spock in ST III, a sequence called “Stealing the Enterprise” on the soundtrack album.
It also bears mentioning that Spock did more mutiny/Enterprise-stealin’ of his own in The Menagerie. Sarek’s kids truly are menaces.
Am I the only one who thought Lt Mitchell got a LOT of screen time this episode? Depending on what happens with her later in the series I’m wondering if they are planning to move Rong Fu (the name of her actress) to series regular next season.
That would be rad. I felt like she got a little more screen time towards the end of season 1 as well. Maybe they just like working with her.
(Continued from main post)
Uhura’s PADD identifies the Klingons meeting with La’An (to buy phaser pistols) as speaking an obscure dialect called Kach-Ugh. She manages to decipher that whatever is being planned is happening tomorrow.
Spock calls up to Transporter Chief Jay, who informs him that they lost M’Benga and Chapel’s signals an hour ago. The pair are brought to a huge cave, hollowed out from decades of mining, which has a Federation starship M’Benga thinks the faction built themselves.
Inside, M’Benga treats a Klingon (Ro’Quegh) with ion burns that are normally too severe to treat, but Klingons had a redundant dermal system (like many other Klingon organs: TNG: “Ethics”).
M’Benga was stationed on the moon of J’gal, and after the Battle of ChaKana, there was so much blood in the air that the rain turned red. Klingon blood was established as pink/purple in ST VI, but its depiction on screen has not been consistent.
Chapel says that the severity of the burns suggest the torpedoes are on this ship. M’Benga theorizes that they are going to use the Federation tech to attack the Klingons and restart the war.
M’Benga always carries a vial of green liquid with him that when injected gives him and Chapel enhanced strength and aggression, which they use to beat down a group of guards. He beats answers out of a Klingon: 30 soldiers on the bridge and engineering, armed with phasers, phase rifles and Klingon disruptors, and a transponder on Deck 13.
M’Benga reprograms the transponder to send a simple message which usually only sends out the name and class of a Federation ship. They escape through Airlock 5-E but the ship takes off.
A Klingon D7 battlecruiser warps into orbit. The Enterprise is hiding in Cajitar IV’s rings, which are interstellar ice with a high iron content, so she looks like space junk. Ortegas says she’s hidden from enough Klingons to know when to take a breather, indicating she also served in the war.
La’An says her contacts in the Broken Circle have vanished. That must be the name of the faction that plans to restart the war.
Mitchell identifies the faction ship as a Crossfield-class (same class as Discovery), but it doesn’t really look like one, resembling more an Akira-class. Perhaps this is the standard Crossfield configuration and Discovery and her sister ship Glenn were variants.
Uhura picks up M’Benga’s message (in Morse 2) from the transponder: “Enterprise, destroy this ship.”
The transponders in EV suits activate automatically once they are in the vacuum of space. The D7’s disruptors are mounted on the sides of the nacelles. M’Benga says it will take about a minute for them to die in space, but they will lose consciousness after 15 seconds. While he’s correct about the latter, it should take about 90 seconds before you die from asphyxiation.
The Captain of the D7 is named D’Chok. Spock says he has been known to drink bloodwine, which surprises D’Chok. Pelia interprets D’Chok’s toast as, “May your blood scream,” which Spock implies has to do with how drinking bloodwine feels.
Spock is visibly affected by bloodwine and gets a hangover, although he states in TOS: “The Conscience of the King” that “My father’s race was spared the dubious effects of alcohol.” It may be that the alcohol is acting on his human side. Though we know Vulcan port (DS9: “The Maquis, Part I”) exists, it is unclear if that produces an intoxicating effect in Vulcans or if it is intended for imbibing by non-Vulcans.
Pelia wears a Starfleet delta with a black backing, indicating the Academy, along with another insignia which resembles the flower-like insignia worn by starbase personnel in TOS. Lanthanites are almost immortal and lived on Earth, undetected, until the 22nd Century. Amanda was one of the first people Pelia came out to and she says the worst thing about living almost forever is boredom - echoing Zefram Cochran’s words in TOS: “Metamorposis”: “Believe me, Captain, immortality consists largely of boredom.” Her longevity and experience marks her as potentially a similar advisor-type character as Guinan in TNG.
The war April is worried about centers on what appears to be an incursion by a Gorn attack ship in proximity to Deep Space 2, the Galdonterre system (DS9: “Blood Oath”) and the Cestus system (TOS: “Arena”), the latter two of which are established in Geoffrey Mandel’s Star Charts as near the border between the Federation, the Klingon Empire and the Gorn Hegemony.
The episode is dedicated “For Nichelle, who was first through the door and showed us the stars. Hailing frequencies forever open…” in memory of the late Nichelle Nichols, who was both a pioneer as a major black female character on TOS in the day and later worked with NASA to recruit people of color to the astronaut program.
One thing I have to note in more detail is that with the star chart showing Cestus and delineating the boundaries of Gorn space, we are getting further and further away from what was established in TOS: “Arena”.
While thus far we can handwave Sulu not recognizing the Gorn vessel as being an unfamiliar Gorn ship class, try and interpret the dialogue of Spock and McCoy has not recognizing that specific species of Gorn, or even - less plausibly - Kirk not being aware of the Gorn in the first place, the large continuity issue that looms here is that in “Arena” they should be well aware they are at the very least near Gorn space.
The dialogue in “Arena” explicitly states that the Cestus III outpost was established in ignorance of the fact that it was in Gorn space. McCoy even asks if that makes the Federation the bad guys in this scenario. With the chart seen in SNW: “The Broken Circle”, this excuse rings hollow. Granted, at this point Cestus still lies outside Gorn borders, but surely there would have been some discussion about that if Spock, et al. had been aware of it or if the Gorn had indeed pushed forward to claim that area of space.
We can still sort of handwave it because Cestus isn’t in Gorn space on the map, but we’re treading closer to major revisions to “Arena” here which might not be able to be handwaved away as I’ve suggested above.
The showrunners have hinted that they’re gonna play a little loose with established canon this season – I think in particular with regard to Spock/Chapel, but also likely with the Gorn. Which honestly is an interesting choice – SNW is supposed to appeal to folks who miss TOS (and the vibe of TNG, even if LDS and PIC are more literal successors to TNG), and so I wonder if they are counting on that “credibility” to seek “forgiveness” from fans who object to continuity issues.
(On the other hand, they also seem to be doubling down on certain elements from canon; for example, they are taking very seriously this notion that 2250s Spock is noticeably greener, no pun intended, than 2260s Spock, drawing much more on “The Cage” than his later appearances. To me, this is in contrast to the Kelvinverse interpretation of the character, who, while still more emotive than 2260s Spock Prime, nevertheless seems to be drawing primarily from that version of Spock, rather than the one from “The Cage”.)
I’m not sure if it contradicts Arena so long as we never have a face-to-face confrontation with adult Gorn.
We know by the 2380s the Gorn are on better terms with the Federation, so it would be cool to somehow flesh out Gorn culture even in SNW.
The difficulties are not about the physical appearance of the Gorn - it’s about the fact of the Gorn’s existence in the first place (Kirk being seemingly ignorant of the species name) and that they didn’t know Cestus III could be considered an incursion on Gorn territory.
KIRK: I have been somehow whisked off the bridge and placed on the surface of an asteroid, facing the captain of the alien ship. Weaponless, I face the creature the Metrons called a Gorn.
and
MCCOY: Can that be true? Was Cestus III an intrusion on their space?
SPOCK: It may well be possible, Doctor. We know very little about that section of the galaxy.
MCCOY: Then we could be in the wrong.
Then again, McCoy does refer to the alien as a “Gorn” without seemingly having previously heard the name (there are multiple possible explanations for this), so there’s that. My point really was that mental gymnastics already need to be employed to square “Arena” with SNW, and we’re getting into areas which need even more.
well, perhaps the Farragut is on the other side of the Federation, and the foreshadowed conflict with the Gorn might play out in some way where they end up not going very far into that region of space?
(Is this the aforementioned mental gymnastics?)
Yep. The map shows Cestus right there close to outlined Gorn territory, so the establishment of Cestus III being seen as an incursion on Gorn space can’t really be much of a surprise - at least not in the way Spock put it in TOS: “Arena”.
Spock is visibly affected by bloodwine and gets a hangover, although he states in TOS: “The Conscience of the King” that “My father’s race was spared the dubious effects of alcohol.”
Personally I always took that not as “Vulcans aren’t affected by alcohol”, but “Vulcans historically have no culture of drinking.”
‘Being spared the effects of alcohol’ could indicate that Vulcans aren’t affected by it. Their blood chemistry being different may mean their bodies don’t metabolize alcohol the way humans’ do, and so there’s no hangover because of the lack of metabolic issues.
Not drinking enough to get hungover/at all technically ‘spares’ one from a hangover, but that phrasing would be strange and clunky. It’d be like telling someone who just got sunburned at the beach that “I never get sunburned at the beach” to convey that I don’t go to the beach, when just saying “I never go to the beach” is a direct statement that logically precludes sunburns from beachgoing.
What’s up with that “Crossfield” class anyway? Clearly a refit after the end of Discovery or a misidentification I think.
I also didn’t make the connection of the black backing indicating the Academy or the Starbase personnel flower-emblem, but this makes sense since she would be an officer and the only other Academy badges we’ve seen are worn by cadets. Assuming that when she says “she teaches” that means she is currently teaching, perhaps out of a Starbase. Although, I wonder why only Pelia wears the flower-emblem when there are other starbase personnel who seem to be wearing standard issue uniforms.
To be honest, it resembles the starbase insignia but it isn’t quite the same as what we see in TOS, so it could mean something else entirely.
The ship looked kitbashed from a Crossfield hull and something else to me. I assume it’s a war wreck they salvaged and rebuilt on the moon for this purpose.
The Disco and the Glenn were the two spore drive bearing Crossfield class ships, but I doubt they were the only ones as they could be fit with a normal warp drive too.
It might be a standard Crossfield class ship, not heavily modified like the Glenn and Discovery and this is just what they normally look like when they aren’t refitted for mushroom engines.
It definitely looks to be made of a Crossfield primary hull with Constitution nacelles, and maybe a Miranda style rollbar on top. It did give me the kitbash feeling and the idea that the Klingons salvaged maybe two ships to create one is kind of interesting.
