Any post and community could be accessed through a theoretically limitless amount of instances, which also means a theoretically limitless amount of URLs.
Will this hinder Lemmy from ever coming into the mainstream? If I type any topic in Google, I will get a reddit thread that deals with that. Can something like that ever happen for Lemmy?
I think if canonicals are applied correctly, it should not be an issue?
I think you’re right. Looking at the html source for this page I don’t see a canonical tag, though. Maybe they haven’t added it yet? Or I missed it.
Would the canonical tag make any sense for Lemmy? The problem is, if you search for something your preferred site / URL is your instance. So the canonical would be different for every user?
The canonical makes sense for the search engine (eg Google). I would put the canonical on the source instance.
Leaves open the question what would happen if the source would disappear…
Yeah, I think that’s one of the user experience issues we’re facing. Setting the canonical as the original server makes the most sense, but that would mean if you find something interesting via a search engine you have to figure out how to get it to show up on your home instance.
Like for me, since I run my own instance for myself and one other person so far, I have to find interesting communities manually. It’s really annoying. Though, looking at Lemmy v0.18 release notes, a lot of new devs have made contributions and I’m sure more will help in the future. One improvement from yesterday’s release is visiting a remote community on your home server will pull the community rather than returning a
404. I think changes like that are big first steps towards improving this specific aspect of the user experience.
This is in fact my biggest worry of Lemmy’s future. People need to be able to search for stuff and I currently don’t see how.
I’m doing tests in the next couple days. But I’m trying to build a search engine specifically for Lemmy.
- It should in theory work similar-ish to Google / Bing.
- You can filter by instance, community or author.
- it only indexes Lemmy posts and it won’t keep duplicates.
- It’ll also open any link you find in your instance.
- You’ll be able to self host it and point it to any instance you want as well.
I’m hoping I can open it to the public in a week or so.
Cool! How does it technically work? Does it fetch all titles (and maybe the body and comments) via the api from each instance or do you set up your own private instance and tap into the instance database?
I’m using the public API to grab every post / comment and then I essentially replace the content with only the unique words. Then when you go to search it just looks for any post or comment, in my database, that has the words you typed in. Finally I sort based on the number of upvotes.
Right now it only craws a specific instance that you point it to. But as long as that instance is federated it /should/ get everything. But eventually I plan on using that instance’s list of federated instances to scan everything and lighten the load on any one particular instance.
Edit: I thought about tapping into the existing database but the existing database is more geared towards serving content but not necessarily searching. The database that I’m building you can search but I drop so much of the original data that using it for content is worthless.
Now I’m curious what your stack is? Are you using an elastic database? Have you considered possibly using something like Azure Cognitive Search (hosted Elastic with AI/ML functions to add some NLP to your data/queries)? Bing uses it as part of their backend.
HTML + JavaScript frontend. Rust backend with a postgres database.
It’ll be open sourced once I can get the MVP ready.
Please make sure that you’re only indexing Lemmy communities and Kbin magazines (i.e. not microblogs)
In the wider fediverse, there is an actual expectation of privacy beyond “well it’s technically possible to scrape everything so we may as well give up”. Several people (with reasons of innocent naivete & explicit and blatant malice alike) have tried making fediverse search engines, but all of them are either dead or blocked.
Lemmy/Kbin is in a unique position where global search does make some sense to have, due to it being a public forum focused on topics (and not people), but there is a very real chance that assholes could use an “unbounded” fediverse search engine to find vulnerable people (quite a few of them specifically fleeing to the fediverse to avoid that kind of problem) and harass them.
The concept of privacy within today’s Fediverse is asinine and everyone should be pointing that out at every opportunity. Doing otherwise, making believe that some sort of code of conduct or public shame cycle is somehow going to keep people safe, is ridiculous and even more dangerous than a public search engine. By not talking about, very loudly, just how trivial it is to gather this data and how impossible it is to remove it we’re sticking our heads in the sand and there will be people who suffer as a result.
Feel free to go do that then
Would it be possible to also integrate kbin?
deleted by creator
It’s probably the search engine that is unfriendly to Lemmy and others.
I like you philosophical view of the matter
Currently it appears that a non-logged-in user (try an incognito window!) will only see posts on a particular server’s local communities. So a search engine bot crawling multiple Lemmy servers will only see duplicates if they’ve been explicitly crossposted.
No, you can definitely browse “all” while logged out. It just defaults to local.
Yes I’m sure that it won’t take too long for search engines to cotton on and start indexing Fediverse stuff - after all it’s going to be getting linked from other sites, which will cause the spider to head to the source URL and start having a gander.
I think so, at least compared to more centralised sites, since there’s no index or aggregator that concentrates that information in a place that can be easily accessible.
Unlike some place like Reddit, I can’t just stick “Lemmy” or “site:lemmy.ml” on the end of my link, and expect that I would be able to get all the information across all the instances. At best, I would be able to search for what’s contained within an individual instance, but that’s about it, which makes it more trouble to search for things, since you have to know the server and community you’re looking for first.
