YearOfTheCommieDesktop [they/them]

  • 7 Posts
  • 63 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: July 12th, 2023

help-circle



  • I went digging for where this had been posted before but it turns out it was just the mega: https://hexbear.net/comment/4668021

    I tend to agree with @the_itsb in being exceedingly skeptical of the takeaways and premise here

    Also this guy insists Chunka Luta are nazis on twitter iirc which is also deeply sus behavior without any evidence

    maybe revolution is not just around the corner, maybe its another thousand years of worsening barbarism, idk, but being like “hmm yes maybe our best chance is to let the corporations win and devolve into a pure monopoly and then take over that monopoly at some nebulous point in the future” is just counter fucking productive. We do have power to affect the world even if we can’t topple global capitalism in the near term and anyone encouraging longtermism adjacent, or doomer adjacent ideas like this is worse than the most naive “any day now capitalism will fall” baby socialist

    his answer is literally “marxism will let me be self righteously satisfied with my understanding of the world and hopeful for the distant future while I do nothing (or maybe participate in an uprising, as long as its rooted in the understanding it will change nothing)”

    like come on. if you are that doom brained why are you even a socialist?

    He could have written a more persuasive version of this article if he like, advocated for doing anything despite his feeling that the odds are long, but he seems happy to concede that nothing need be done because the conditions aren’t right. when the conditions become right, people like this will be out in the cold because they havent been fighting and organizing in preparation












  • imma be honest I have a hard time giving a shit whether or not some guy I’ve never read misinterpreted marx or not.

    What’s obvious to me is that in the near term a lot needs to change about production everywhere and allocation of resources in the global north especially, if we are to slow down/reverse climate change and survive it. Does this imply a permanent limit on production or population? No. But like, it might be a while before we get this shit under control, if we ever do.

    In the meantime, reallocating resources does not have to come with a loss of quality of life. If I never flew on a plane again but I had enough time off of work to take a train instead, that would be a net increase in quality of life. If instead of the primary way of getting around for 95% of americans being a car, it was public transit, that would be an improvement, not a decline in QoL. The list goes on. Living slower (in some respects), simpler, less wasteful lives, is not an inherent regression in society, more production isn’t inherently better when the things being produced and the process of production are both fucked and making people’s lives worse.








  • The relevant question isn’t “did he break the law”, but “did NK mistreat him, or neglect him in custody, causing his illness”? I haven’t seen any evidence they caused his illness through mistreatment, and it’d be pretty much impossible to prove so long after the fact if they did, unless said mistreatment involved broken bones or something. But what is much more believable is him being assaulted, perhaps strangled, by other prisoners upon incarceration, which would explain the “lack of oxygen to the brain” that the coroners report mentioned.

    The DPRK authorities have some responsibility, if they are going to imprison him, to make sure that doesn’t happen, IMO. It would fall under neglect. I mean either way he’s no martyr, I certainly don’t condemn the DPRK for it, but I think it’s fair to say they could have handled it better. If this were one case out of dozens, or hundreds, of americans getting arrested in the DPRK, and one guy happens to get sick and go into a coma in custody, I’d be happy to accept it was coincidence or just stress, but it’s not a common occurrence for an american to go to prison there, and americans are (rightly) hated there, so it’s sorta hard to accept a healthy US college student just abruptly went into a vegetative coma with no acute cause besides stress when there are so many other possibilities that seem much more likely and simple.