I’ve seen too much of this. No, the nazis and the Soviets were not equivalent.

Do. Better.

  • CommieAVGN [none/use name]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    edit-2
    1 year ago

    Alright, comrades, put on your thinking caps, because we’re diving into the cesspool of historical oversimplification, and it smells like capitalist pig slop! Let’s break down this capitalist propaganda down piece by piece:

    1. Nazi Extermination: No bones about it – the Nazis were grade-A shitheads. Their systematic and conscious decision to wipe out around 12 million people in the name of ethnic cleansing is a crime against humanity. Period. It’s the darkest level in the game of human history, and they played it with sadistic glee.

    2. Soviet Extermination for Political Reasons: 1.6 million? That’s a hefty (and grossly inaccurate) number, comrade, but let’s add a little context, shall we? No one’s saying the Soviet regime was always all rainbows and kittens. But you’ve got to understand the political climate and the paranoia of the times. I ain’t condoning it, but I sure as hell am not going to let you oversimplify it into a neat little bullet point for your anti-communist agenda. Many of those deaths were during the Civil War and the turbulent times that followed.

    3. Starvation Numbers: Ah, the classic “Stalin starved millions” narrative. While there’s truth to the great famine, pinning it all on “gross ineptitude” is like blaming a game’s poor graphics entirely on one pixel. Factors like weather conditions, and yes, mismanagement, played a role. But to toss out numbers like 3.5 - 5.0 million as if it’s just another score on a leaderboard? Classy.

    Alright, now let’s delve into the issue of “intentionality” even deeper. While you’re busy playing the “Evil Olympics”, let’s not forget some important nuances:

    The big ol’ narrative floating around is that both the Nazis and the Soviets had these grand plans to exterminate people like it’s some fucked up DLC they both decided to download. But here’s where you’re more twisted than a pretzel in a tornado: while the Nazis clearly and explicitly had extermination policies (hello, Final Solution), the Soviets were a different beast. The Soviet government never launched a campaign with the explicit aim of exterminating entire ethnic or political groups. Sure, there were purges, relocations, and episodes of repression. The likes of the Holodomor, where millions died due to a famine in Ukraine in the early 1930s, is a tragic event in Soviet history. But labeling it as a deliberate attempt at extermination? That’s like trying to speedrun a game without knowing the controls.

    Now, did the Soviet regime have policies that inadvertently or through neglect may have led to death? Yes. Did they, like the Nazis, have a master plan for the systematic extermination of entire groups? No. The two are not the same, no matter how much some armchair historians want to mash them together. See, history ain’t a black and white pixel art game. It’s a complex, 4K, multi-layered RPG. And trying to simplify it with broad brushstrokes does a disservice to everyone who lived, suffered, and died during those times. So, next time you want to drop “facts”, make sure you’ve got the full game manual, not just the cheat codes.