SW Engineer, Amateur mathematician (contributed to metamath.org, oeis.org, …), Legal Tourist (went to Honolulu in 2010 to watch the end of Sancho v. DOE).

  • 0 Posts
  • 1 Comment
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: December 16th, 2022

help-circle
  • @ajsadauskas @technology @music@fedibb.ml @music@lemmy.ml

    #Copyright does not protect the concept and themes of artistic presentation. So training autocomplete tools like #ChatGPT or generative art tools along the lines of #StabilityAI on huge amounts of copyrighted material available on the web doesn’t seem to trespass on the rights actually created by copyright law. That is, neither the trained model parameters nor the output qualifies as a infringing copy.

    The fact that big corporations have heated the rhetoric with even small-scale copyright infringement being characterized as if it were an existential threat rather than free marketing perhaps misleads people to think copyright grants the owner total control of the future of their creations. But law is about statutes and precedents, not feelings, which is why big corporations aren’t likely to train their models on billions of copyrighted works if there was a credible risk of paying statutory damages on a per-work basis.

    If there is a moral right to the “something” that has been gifted to these models by their training, it has not been well described, let alone recognized in law as property of the creators. How is this “something” which an AI model steals supposed to be distinguished from the piecewise appreciation for the art as summed over all human viewers?

    So perhaps the real problem is the moral outrage created by the corporations who for decades equate copyright infringement with being ambushed by a gang of seagoing rapists, kidnappers, killers, and robbers (pirates). Towards that end, Germany is discussing adding copyright infringement as a form of “digital violence” making the analogy more exact.

    https://www.techdirt.com/2023/05/05/germany-wants-to-include-copyright-infringement-under-its-planned-digital-violence-law/