• huginn
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    18
    ·
    3 months ago

    Nobody is right about everything - you can’t blindly follow even the most brilliant minds.

    You’ve gotta take the good where you find it and work out a philosophy that works for you. Plenty of good to be pulled from Chomsk

    • NoiseColor@startrek.website
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      6
      ·
      3 months ago

      For sure. I have much respect for the man and everything he has done. The reason I stopped having him in the highest regard is not that he got some stuff wrong, but that I started taking him as academic in the sense that his view is limited by the direction of his studies. I don’t think he has a deep grasp on how the world works, because he has spent more than half a century preaching the same stuff. I don’t think he is the kind of man, who can step away from his work and say there is more to global politics than American hegemony, if I can exaggerate a bit. The are certain grey areas and paradoxes in the world that chomsky tries to rationalize, but fails to notice how incredibly subjective his academic viewpoint is.

      What I resented recently was his comments on Ukraine, where he couldn’t get out of his skin and immediately tried to put invasion of Ukraine into context of American wars. He should have been completely aware that that is exactly what the worst of Russian propagandists are saying. Ok, he is really old now, but Geez.

      Anyway, incredible body of work of great importance.