I don’t want right-wing fanatics…I don’t want leftist fanatics…I want a place where all views can be discussed with respect and civility. /r/politics was NOT that place. I hope Lemmy can avoid the echo chamber to allow respectful disagreement and discourse to occur (while not overly defending extremists on either side).

I like to believe there is much more we agree upon than disagree…and while not always the case, sometimes we need to take a moment to ensure we aren’t talking passed each other and be willing to listen to understand (even if you don’t agree in the end). It’s okay to disagree as long as you respect one another.

“If you want to be heard, first learn to listen.” - John F. Kennedy

  • carlyman@lemmy.mlOP
    3·
    1 year ago

    Popper’s Paradox of tolerance underscores the need for thoughtful consideration, but it doesn’t dismiss the importance of civil discourse. Popper himself called for the “tolerance of the intolerant” within the bounds of rational criticism highlights that while we acknowledge the limits of tolerance, engaging in respectful dialogue remains crucial. By upholding civil discourse, challenging ideas through reasoned arguments, and embracing Popper’s notion, we can maintain a tolerant society while fostering understanding and progress.

    • DevCat@lemmy.world
      2·
      1 year ago

      As he says:

      …as long as we can counter them by rational argument and keep them in check by public opinion, suppression would certainly be most unwise

      This would, of course, require that they make their argument in good faith. Unfortunately, this is an ability that has too often eluded the right wing.

      • carlyman@lemmy.mlOP
        3·
        1 year ago

        I guess for me…folks should try to assume good intentions at the start. I often find (any/all sides) quickly put up defenses, presume the worst, and find ways to be insulted where they wouldn’t have if they were also behaving in good faith. Assholes exist, but let them prove that they are first.

        • spaceghoti@lemmy.one
          2·
          1 year ago

          Yes, I agree. Let them prove it first. But too many “enlightened centrists” place the bar for proof so high that it’s impossible. When Democrats conceded 95% of Republicans’ demands in the 2015 budget, Republicans complained about not getting the entire 100% and centrists said “we should listen to them.”

          There comes a point where the fetish for civility goes too far. We’ve long passed that in US politics.